Spectra S1 VS Medela Swing Maxi Flex
Last Updated: 20 December 2024
So, which one should you choose? The great and terrible recurring question of motherhood, which one do I choose?! We hate to say it again but… It’s your decision at the end of the day. That’s okay though, because we’re going to deep dive into each of them to the point where the answer becomes clear to you which one suits your lifestyle, needs, and budget the best.
Pricing
In terms of pricing, the Spectra S1 is marked at approximately ZAR 3,899, whereas the Medela Swing Maxi Flex is priced higher, around ZAR 6,999. Both pumps are recognized by medical aids, potentially allowing for reimbursement. However, given the general limits on medical aid coverage for breast pumps, which may not fully cover the cost of the Medela Swing Maxi, the Spectra S1 emerges as a more financially viable option if you’re aiming to minimise out-of-pocket expenses.
Pumping Technology & Strength
The Medela Swing Maxi™ Flex breast pump is designed for ease of use, featuring intuitive controls with four buttons and clear icons for its main functions. It offers nine pre-programmed settings to help users find their most comfortable vacuum level. It employs 2-Phase Expression™ technology to mimic a baby’s natural feeding pattern, starting with quick sucks to stimulate milk flow, followed by slower cycle for efficient milk collection. This technology aims to optimise milk flow, with a maximum vacuum strength of 250 mmHg.
The Spectra S1 breast pump, with a maximum suction strength of 270mmHg, is a hospital-grade pump designed for frequent daily use. It incorporates Natural Nursing Technology™ for a comfortable pumping experience, simulating a baby’s natural nursing behaviour. The S1 features adjustable settings in both let-down and expression modes, including a unique capability to adjust vacuum levels independently of speed, enhancing efficiency. Additionally, it offers a memory function, timer, and night light for convenience, making it a versatile choice for mothers.
Portability
Both the Medela Swing Maxi Flex and the Spectra S1 are equipped with rechargeable batteries, making them ideal for South African mothers facing load shedding. The Medela’s battery can last around to 2.5 hours or about six pumping sessions, and it features a USB Type C connector for fast recharging, compatible with strong power banks.
The Spectra S1, offering up to 3 hours of use per charge, is a bit bulkier, reflecting its hospital-grade designation, which might affect portability compared to the lighter and more compact Medela Swing Maxi Flex.
Sound & Discretion
Both the Medela Swing Maxi Flex and the Spectra S1 are recognized for their quiet operation, making them suitable for use during work calls or in the late hours without disturbing others. They operate at around 45 dB at maximum vacuum level, comparable to the quiet ambiance of a library, ensuring a discreet pumping experience wherever you are.
Availability of Spare Parts
Maintaining a breast pump involves periodic replacement of parts to ensure optimal performance. Medela, being a well-established brand in South Africa, offers easier access to spare parts. Spectra S1 parts may be slightly harder to find locally, but an online retailer, Pandylane, provides a convenient solution for ordering and delivering these parts nationwide. This ensures that regardless of the pump you choose, support and maintenance are manageable.
Handsfree pumping Accessories
In the realm of hands-free pumping accessories, Spectra takes the lead with its hands-free kit designed to fit inside your bra, providing a seamless pumping experience. Medela, while offering hands-free bustiers and bras, does not have a distinct hands-free bra accessory similar to Spectra’s integrated solution.
Overall, both the Spectra S1 and the Medela Swing Maxi Flex stand out as top contenders in the world of breast pumps, each offering unique advantages to meet the needs of breastfeeding mothers. The Spectra S1 has earned its place as a cult classic, celebrated for its hospital-grade performance, powerful suction, and gentle yet effective pumping experience. This is reflected in the numerous awards it has garnered, including the 2024 Baby Innovation Award and recognition from Babylist, What to Expect, and Good Housekeeping.
Meanwhile, the Medela Swing Maxi Flex, with its new and improved design, continues to uphold its status as a reliable and efficient pumping classic. Known for its ease of use, portability, and innovative Flex technology, the Swing Maxi Flex provides a comfortable and efficient pumping experience, making it a favorite among many mothers.
Ultimately, whether you choose the Spectra S1 for its unparalleled power and award-winning design, or the Medela Swing Maxi Flex for its convenience and trusted reputation, you can be confident that both pumps are designed to support your breastfeeding journey with ease and reliability.
Our Guidance Pledge
We’re dedicated to providing you with practical, evidence-based information to help you make the best choices for your growing family. All content is medically reviewed by our in-house doctor and/or experts such as OB-GYNs, doulas, and midwives, and is based on the latest international guidelines, peer-reviewed studies, and reputable sources from academic institutions and medical journals. Learn More
